In the past, audio enthusiasts were stuck with a problem: if you wanted to produce and record, you had to book time at a studio, rely on an experienced engineer to tweak all of the controls, and pay by the hour or project to get your ideas down on tape.
These days, virtually anyone can record their own music in their own studio space or even their bedroom using digital audio workstation (DAW) software that is not only comparable to big studios of old but in many cases, is even better.
Unfortunately, although DAW software solves a number of problems, it opens up the door to new ones.
For example, which DAW should you choose? Pro Tools is the answer given by many in the recording industry, but other options like Ableton Live are touted as solutions as well.
To help you make the right choice, I’ve broken down some key differences and similarities when it comes to Pro Tools vs. Ableton Live to help you make an informed choice.
Contents
The Main Differences: Avid Pro Tools vs Ableton Live
Both Pro Tools and Ableton Live are great programs that I have a lot of experience working with. If you’ve spent any amount of time working in studios, you likely know that Pro Tools is and has been the industry standard for decades.
Ableton Live is a more recent addition to the world of recording, but it also packs quite a punch, just in a different way than Pro Tools.
One of the main differences between these two DAW applications is that Ableton Live tends to focus more heavily on audio creation whereas Pro Tools is focused more on the production side of things.
If you need a professional-grade DAW for recording, mixing, and mastering, Pro Tools has all that you need, particularly when you combine it with Avid’s HDX hardware.
If you’re into music creation, Ableton Live has a number of tools to let you create and produce with ease, and its layout is often helpful in keeping everything separated, neat, and orderly.
Avid Pro Tools: Quick Summary
- Able to produce across all genres
- Regarded as the industry standard
- Pro Tools | Carbon is a must-have interface
Avid Pro Tools Features & Benefits
Even if you’ve heard of Pro Tools before, you may have some questions about what makes it so great. I’ve included some answers below:
Recording, mixing, and mastering for all genres
One of the things I find most useful about Pro Tools is its versatility when working with all genres. In fact, I have yet to find a genre of music or an audio project that Pro Tools could not handle.
Pro Tools for hip-hop production makes it easy to ingest samples and arrange them for vocal tracking. Pro Tools for rock music is great because I can add so many tracks and DSP effects to craft a clean, modern sound.
If I’m working with a large group of artists, Pro Tools for orchestral recording or even big band arrangements is a breeze when working with Pro Tools | Ultimate.
Knowing Pro Tools enhances career opportunities
By and large, you have to know Pro Tools if you plan to work in the recording industry. Pro Tools is the standard by which all other DAW software is measured, and this means that if you don’t know Pro Tools, you’re going to be missing out on a lot of opportunities.
Its interface is easy to navigate and provides access to editing and mixing tools, Pro Tools connects easily with interface components, including Avid’s own Pro Tools | Carbon interface and I can use plenty of high-end, professional-grade plugins when working with Pro Tools.
Avid has proven that it is dedicated to carrying on the Pro Tools legacy that began over 30 years ago. Today, Pro Tools remains the top choice among major studios and professional engineers for music, film, television, soundstage work, and live performance audio production.
>>> Related Reading: Avid Pro Tools Review: The Honest Truth
>>> Related Reading: Avid Pro Tools vs Logic Pro: What You Need To Know
Pro Tools | Carbon makes life easy
Speaking of Pro Tools | Carbon, this is one of the biggest benefits of using Pro Tools. This interface was made for use with Pro Tools, so it performs beautifully.
Whether I’m using up to 256 tracks with the standard Pro Tools version or I’m working on thousands of tracks through Pro Tools | Ultimate, the Pro Tools | Carbon interface can handle whatever I throw at it.
It features eight processor cores, allowing me the ability to use the latest in DSP effects without having to bounce tracks or create stems. Pro Tools | Carbon is also an example of how forward-thinking Avid is when it comes to hardware.
The brand produces HDX hardware for use with Pro Tools, and each piece of gear is designed to work flawlessly with the DAW while expanding on software functionality and power.
Ableton Live: Quick Summary
- User interface is intuitive and efficient
- Max for Live boosts functionality for creators
- Ableton Live serves as a performance tool
Ableton Live Features & Benefits
Because Ableton is a more recent DAW addition to the music industry, you may not be as familiar with its features. I’ve outlined some of my favorites below to help you decide whether it’s right for your needs:
Session view vs. arrangement view
The UI in Ableton Live is unique in that it doesn’t rely on the traditional horizontal view of tracks used by traditional DAW software. Instead, Ableton Live provides both a session view and an arrangement view that offers a unique perspective of your recording.
In session view, you can see clips, make edits and create scenes, which are essentially blocks that will be laid out in arrangement view. Each block can then be moved around in the arrangement view to lay out the fundamentals of the song.
These scenes can be moved and edited during a live performance as well. Using this method of composition, things are kept simple and organized, and with both views, you can see what needs to be changed, how edits are affecting the overall track, and more.
Max for Live adds a whole new layer of functionality
Max for Live is a unique approach to virtual instruments and effects in Ableton Live. Using Max for Live, you have the ability to use pre-made effects and instrument modules as well as MIDI effects, but you can also create your own.
This extends the functionality of Ableton Live and once again demonstrates how it is a wonderful DAW solution for creators and writers.
Using Max for Live modules, you have the ability to enhance a song, and you also have the ability to set your track apart from others by customizing your own effects to get a signature sound.
Become a virtual DJ using Ableton Live
One of the key selling points of Ableton Live is the “live” portion of the program. In this, Ableton Live allows you to act as a virtual DJ by giving you the ability to control a performance on the fly.
You can also add or remove loops as a track plays, make quick edits, add effects, change tempos, and more – it can all be done while a track is playing, once again making Ableton Live a fantastic tool for creators.
This is also beneficial for creating remixes or for trying out ideas as they come up. If an idea works, you’re able to record it as changes are made so that you don’t miss out on a really cool moment.
Who is Avid Pro Tools Best Suited For?
In my experience, Pro Tools is best suited for audio professionals who need a serious solution for big projects. This isn’t to say that Pro Tools doesn’t work well for smaller studios or home recording, because it excels at these things.
It’s just to point out that you’re likely to experience the main benefit from Pro Tools vs. Ableton Live when you need a DAW that can deliver some serious power and advanced features.
Pro Tools is available as a standard version and as Pro Tools | Ultimate. Each of these versions offers something for audio professionals with different needs.
For example, standard Pro Tools includes the ability to include 64 I/O, but Pro Tools | Ultimate can accommodate up to 192 I/O with the addition of HDX hardware. Likewise, the standard edition includes 128 aux inputs while Pro Tools | Ultimate can handle 512.
Although Pro Tools includes plenty of tools for composition and production, its major selling point is its functionality in terms of recording, mixing, and mastering.
Standard Pro Tools can handle up to 256 mono/stereo audio tracks, but Pro Tools | Ultimate gives you the power to work on up to 2,048 audio tracks and surround sound.
Additionally, Avid’s inclusion of HDX hardware like the Pro Tools | Carbon interface means that you’re going to enjoy a seamless experience when recording large, processor-heavy projects for music, film, or live production.
Who is Ableton Live Best Suited For?
Ableton Live is often the go-to choice for people focused exclusively on producing music since this DAW is heavily focused on the composition and arrangement side of audio production as opposed to recording and mixing.
Although learning Ableton Live takes a little bit more time if you’re coming from the traditional session view of a DAW like Pro Tools, it’s pretty intuitive once you’ve got the hang of things.
With the addition of things like Max for Live, creating music in Ableton Live is both fun and freeing. While Ableton Live is probably not going to be used in many major studios for large recording projects, it’s still a good idea to know as many DAW titles as possible to make yourself an asset in the recording world.
So, Which One Should You Choose?
I’m always cautious to recommend a specific DAW to anyone because tastes vary and needs differ. I will say that I think Pro Tools is always going to be a solid choice for anyone who plans to pursue a career in pro audio.
Pro Tools is the industry standard for a reason, and if you plan to work in various studios across a number of genres, being proficient in Pro Tools is going to open all kinds of doors for you.
On the other hand, if your focus is on bedroom production or working on projects in a small studio space, Ableton Live may be a good stepping stone in your path toward a larger career in pro audio where Pro Tools will make more sense.
You can take advantage of Avid’s current promotional offer and save up to 50% on your next purchase. Click here to learn more.
Kevin is the founder of Music With Flavor, which joined Whipped Cream Sounds in 2023. He is a seasoned musician turned industry expert. His passion for music goes beyond melodies; he delves deep into the intricate world of music marketing, striving to unearth the most effective strategies for indie musicians. However, Music With Flavor isn’t just about Kevin’s knowledge; it’s a network of industry experts handpicked to provide the most trusted advice. Kevin’s role is to pose the right questions, not just answer them, as he and his team tirelessly research trends, connect with artists, and gather valuable insights.